Rosen's Overrated/Underrated players

0 Kudos

Author	Comment
Spurred1	Rosen's Overrated/Underrated players	Lead	[-]
Gunner's Mate Posts: 957 (07/28/09 11:01) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Tags : None Ran across this lovely tidbit-please note that there are no Lakers on the overrated list, but that would be due to Rosen's overwhelming and permanent hard on for Phil Jackson. http://msn.foxsports.com/nba/story/9...rated-players? He also rubbed his two brain cells together to compile an underrated list... http://msn.foxsports.com/nba/story/9...rated-players? While I agree with some of his assessments, he seems to be missing the fact that some of those overrated players aren't considered "stars" and are not really expected to lead their teams anywhere. Unless one believes that Corey Maggette is a franchise player. I apologize if this has already been posted. I didn't see it here, so...
magnificentbastard		#1	[-]
Gunner's Mate Posts: 1237 (07/28/09 11:05) DB Veteran Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Wonder why Tariq Abdul Wahad didn't make the underrated list?
pepperfletch		#2	[-]
Ship's Captain Posts: 18792 (07/28/09 11:05) DB Habanero Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Please that picture you are using is BAD and I do not mean good..wink
magnificentbastard		#3	[-]
Gunner's Mate Posts: 1238 (07/28/09 11:13) DB Veteran Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Also, is Charlie Rosen so incapable of finding anything to write about that he had to stretch this out over two separate articles? Also, is he such bad a writer that he can't write some sort of segue to at least acknowledge that he turned one article into two?
you		#4	[-]
Pirate Posts: 356 (07/28/09 11:17) DB Member Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Rosen loathes anything Mavs and coddles his little Lakers like he's breastfeeding them. Its deep in his core. Charlie Rosen is a bitter old hack. He's like the elderly guy down the block who is clinging to his good years with bitter hands.
SmokeMaxX		#5	[-]
Gunner's Mate Posts: 1073 (07/28/09 11:17) DB Member Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Lol at Dirk being on the overrated list (honorable mention). SamSaw wrote: all hail dirk nowitski the greatest basketball player ever And1Mak wrote: Go to a Nets board already sheesh. Eddie Sefko wrote: I know it's hard to put your faith in a five-foot-nothin' guy, but Barea has a huge heart and even bigger body parts somewhat lower than the heart.
slickD		#6	[-]
Deckhand Posts: 314 (07/28/09 11:18) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	CP3 in the overrated list??? Wow just wow!
MarionMFFL		#7	[-]
Gunner Posts: 387 (07/28/09 11:18) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	he put Dirk as an honorable mention as Overated. LOL http://i285.photobucket.com/albums/ll78/QuinneyluvsNFL/SHAWNMARIONSIG.png
miles berg		#8	[-]
Ship's Captain Posts: 10640 (07/28/09 11:22) DB's Mel Kiper Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	How anyone can claim Chris Paul or Dirk Nowitzki are overrated is beyond me.
you		#9	[-]
Pirate Posts: 359 (07/28/09 11:23) DB Member Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	miles berg wrote: How anyone can claim Chris Paul or Dirk Nowitzki are overrated is beyond me. ...but yet he managed to leave Pau Gasol and Andrew bynum off of the "overrated" list. I wonder why.
slickD		#10	[-]
Deckhand Posts: 315 (07/28/09 11:25) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	and say Kwame Brown is underrated? Heck from day one in this league he's been nothing but overrated
dude1394		#11	[-]
Official Pirate of the DB Order Posts: 5302 (07/28/09 11:29) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Oh...it's charlie rosen. nevermind. ---------------------- "History will say, it was when you were called upon, you served, and the service you rendered was absolutely necessary to defeat an enemy overseas so we do not have to face them here at home..."
distill3r		#12	[-]
Swab Posts: 36 (07/29/09 12:58) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	wow, i can;t fathom how much of an idiot this guy is.... DIRK? the birdman? shawn marion? CP3? kenyon martin? amare? wow.....
cole1469		#13	[-]
Gunner Posts: 940 (07/29/09 01:13) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Yeah I pretty much disagree with everything Rosen writes.... Just recently he wrote that CP3, Dirk, Duncan, and other great players were not worth max contracts.. but KEVIN GARNETT is worth a max deal... Zeitgeist Movie The Zeitgeist Movement The Venus Project
Hot Kidd		#14	[-]
Gunner Posts: 3098 (07/29/09 01:15) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	WTF...guys...he drops the secret on how to make Paul absolutely impotent. Just double team him. Rosen says double teaming him kills his impact. I have written it down just in case I forget and will immediately email it to Carlisle.
jujuubarukuu		#15	[-]
Swab Posts: 46 (07/29/09 06:57) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I found it odd while reading the two articles that most of the underrated read something like "Can't shoot, but rebounds decently, and can play defense" while most of the overrated stated a bunch of positive qualities about the guy (is a great help side defender, can block shots, gets steals), then mentions that they can't play 1-1 defense. I think the articles should have been titled over/underrated defenders.
DOCTOR LOVE		#16	[-]
Ship's Captain Posts: 14406 (07/29/09 07:07) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	magnificentbastard wrote: Wonder why Tariq Abdul Wahad didn't make the underrated list? Perfect response. Any thread about Rosen without TAW in the initial post or first response is a FAIL. "Well, if that's the case, then as your father I'm asking you, don't draft Pavel Podkolzin." Dialogue from (Men's) Room With A View, Act I, Scene 1
melturpin		#17	[-]
Gunner's Mate Posts: 1798 (07/29/09 07:30) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Chris Paul is a wizard, the best pg since Stockton and Isiah, and arguably better than either. He's never been the Hornets' problem; it's been all the softies they put around him. And Dirk is just always going to be underrated, we might as well face it; because he's a Euro and, despite all his consistent winning, he's never won a ring. That's why. "Indeed, so far from being humorous, the male American is the most abnormally serious creature who ever existed.... It is only fair to admit that he can exaggerate, but even his exaggeration has a rational basis. It is not founded on wit or fancy; it does not spring from any poetic imagination...." -- Oscar Wilde
Shingo		#18	[-]
Pirate Posts: 35 (07/29/09 07:47) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	Rosen's credibility has been in question for a while now. But listing Kwame as underrated just might be the clincher. Charlie, it's time to move along to the Grumpy Old Man's home and see what nurses are overrated.
magnificentbastard		#19	[-]
Gunner's Mate Posts: 1239 (07/29/09 12:53) DB Veteran Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	and say Kwame Brown is underrated? Heck from day one in this league he's been nothing but overrated Do you suppose his Lakers favoritism extends to former Lakers as well? Or at least to the ones that helped them net Gasol? In honor of Kwame's sacrifice he will be forever immortalized in a Charlie Rosen article read only by those who mean to savage it on separate messageboards.
nite1398	I was with him til..	#20	[-]
Swab Posts: 14 (07/29/09 02:32) Reply Quote More My Recent Posts	I got to CP3.. then he absolutely loss all creditablity for the entire article. You can make an NBA title team with those players hands down.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Rosen's Overrated/Underrated players

Rosen's Overrated/Underrated players